With 27 years of dedicated service to the church, Malcolm has held various senior leadership roles, bringing a wealth of experience and insight to the table. His journey began in ministry, where he served as an Executive Pastor, Community Life Pastor, and Lead Pastor across three vibrant congregations. Transitioning to the Leadership Team at Outreach, Inc. in 2012, Malcolm contributed to empowering churches with effective communication strategies to engage their communities.

In 2018, Malcolm took on the role of VP of Recruiting at a prominent national executive search firm, specializing in placing pastors, leaders, and executives within churches and faith-based nonprofits. Praised as "the best recruiter I've hired in 20+ years" by the firm's Founder, Malcolm's proficiency in church leadership, recruiting, marketing, and communications contributed to his outstanding success, resulting in the highest number of placements for the firm during his tenure.

Now, as the Managing Partner of BlueSearch.Co, Malcolm leverages his extensive background to serve as your dedicated recruiter. He is committed to working closely with you to ensure that candidates of the utmost character and competency are presented and ultimately selected for the role.

Outside of his role, Malcolm finds fulfillment in his family life. Married to Rebecca for 29 years, they, along with their three wonderful children - Emily, Andrew, and Olivia - and their family Goldendoodle, Honey, call Colorado home. For further insights into Malcolm's leadership and career journey, feel free to explore his LinkedIn profile.

Malcolm's recent demonstrated experience...

Executive Pastor Encounter Church, Ventura, CA (current)

Lead Pastor - The Pointe Church, Fort Wayne, IN

Lead Pastor - Mountainview Christian Church, Highlands Ranch, CO

Lead Pastor - Palos Verdes Baptist Church, Rolling Hills Estates, CA

Lead Pastor - Encounter Church, Ventura, CA

Lead Pastor - Longmont Calvary, Longmont, CO

Lead Pastor - High Desert Church, Victorville, CA

Christian Ministries Director, Elim Park (Independent Living), Cheshire, CT

President/CEO - Full Strength Network, Fort Wayne, IN

Pastor of Family Ministries - Calvary Church, Los Gatos, CA

Lead Pastor - Valley Community Baptist - Avon, CT

CFO - Food for the Hungry, Phoenix, AZ

"Thanks to Malcolm for his help and superior services!  Without question, we would choose to use him again." 

"I highly recommend Malcolm! We are so pleased with how everything turned out, especially in a season with less viable candidates available." 

"Malcolm had a clear vision of the type of pastor we were looking for and was diligent in identifying candidates who matched our criteria.  I also appreciated that Malcolm prayed with and for us throughout the process."

"Many of our Search Team members commented that “it felt like we had another pastoral care leader” on the team due to Malcolm's leadership and sensitivity to the needs of our search process. "

"Malcolm was very personal and treated us as a friend who they cared about rather than a project to be completed."

"Malcolm was not just very thorough and helpful in this process, but he genuinely cared for and prayed for us throughout the whole process. "

Fees: Our fee structure is straightforward and often lower compared to similar search partners. Blue Search eliminates unnecessary administrative or marketing fees, ensuring transparency. The fee stated in the agreement is the only one associated with the search. Expenses are limited to client/candidate travel. Background checks, education verification, and reference checks are all included.

Follow-up: Blue Search commits to post-placement quarterly check-ins for one year with both the candidate and the church. We prioritize cultural fit, organizational alignment, and profile congruence to foster long-term relationships.

Pastor Wellness Program: Our placements receive a complimentary one-year membership to a Pastor wellness program. This program offers peer-to-peer engagement, leadership coaching, and counseling services to ministry leaders.

Guarantee: Should the placed candidate depart your church within a year, Blue Search will conduct a new search with no additional fee.

Q: Who is the recruiter for our search and are they full-time with your organization?

Your recruiter will be Malcolm Schaad, who dedicates himself to this role full-time - all day, every day. It's essential to ensure your recruiter isn't contracted (1099) or part-time, as they may lack experience or commitment.

Q: How much experience does our recruiter have with Lead Pastor searches?

Malcolm Schaad has successfully placed numerous Lead Pastors in recent years. With a diverse range of churches, from 100-person congregations to those with staff teams exceeding 100, Malcolm brings a wealth of experience in placing Lead Pastors in medium to large churches.

Q: How many searches will our recruiter be working on concurrently (at the same time)?

Malcolm commits to handling no more than four searches concurrently. With our emphasis on engagement and personalized care, managing four searches ensures dedicated attention to each client. It's important to avoid recruiters handling more than four searches, as it may dilute their focus across competing priorities.

Q: Why should we consider a boutique firm like Blue Search over larger search firms with extensive databases and research teams?

While larger search firms may have more resources and research capabilities, it's important to recognize the unique advantages boutique firms offer. At Blue Search, as a solo executive recruiter, Malcolm has consistently delivered top-tier candidates within the same timeframe as larger firms. Here's why:

In summary, while larger firms may offer scale and resources, boutique firms like Blue Search provide personalized attention, tailored approaches, agility, extensive networks, and a proven track record of success—all of which contribute to delivering exceptional results for your Pastor Search.

We Find Great Pastors!